Home » Software Development » Sometimes TDD Requires a Hammer

About Andrew Glover

Andrew Glover

Sometimes TDD Requires a Hammer

While there are myriad mocking libraries available for the Java platform, only a select few of these nifty frameworks is capable of mocking the non-mock-friendly modifiers of static and final. Static (or class) methods, while handy for factories, become a nuisance for a framework like Mockito, however, with the inclusion of PowerMock, you’ve got yourself a proverbial hammer.hammerj

As I wrote about previously, I had to deal with a 3rd party library that is used to integrate with a networked service. This library is essentially hardwired to interact with homebase, which naturally provides some challenges when trying to test ones code that relies on this library. Moreover, the said library contained a static method for creating instances of a specialized class, which, naturally, my code depended on.

PowerMock is made to work in concert with either EasyMock or Mockito; what’s more, it comes with a custom runner for inclusion in JUnit. I’m going to show you how to use PowerMock with Mockito as I happen to find Mockito’s syntax much more fluent than EasyMock’s.

For starters, you’ll need to use two class level annotations – @RunWith for specifying the PowerMockRunner class (this is a JUnit annotation) and another dubbed @PrepareForTest, which takes the class with static methods you wish to mock. @PrepareForTest is provided by PowerMock.

In my case, the class containing a static method is named QTP, accordingly; my test class looks like this:

public class CreateCommandTest {
  public void testCreateRequest() throws Exception {}

Next, in your test method, you use PowerMokito’s mockStatic method, which takes the class (again) with static methods you wish to mock.

public void testCreateRequest() throws Exception {

You can then mock a static method on the class you’ve been passing around to mockStatic and the @PrepareForTest annotation like you would normally do with Mockito. For instance, I can use the when method to specify what I want to happen when this static method is invoked.

public void testCreateRequest() throws Exception {
  QTP qtpThing = mock(QTP.class); //normal Mockito mocking
  //QTP.create is static
  when(QTP.create("dm2q", "0C4F7501UDC8C1EB43B06C988")).thenReturn(qtpThing);
  //QTP.createRecord isn't static
  when(qtpThing.createRecord(any(Tckt.class))).thenReturn(new Long(1000000L));

Finally, you can use PowerMock to ensure your mocked static method is actually invoked. The requirements here are a bit funky; that is, it requires you first specify how many times with one line of code and then you actually call the static method.

public void testCreateRequest() throws Exception {
  QTP.create("dm2q", "0C4F7501UDC8C1EB43B06C988");

Yeah, that’s sorta confusing, I know.

Nevertheless, as most people in the world of Java figured out long ago, static methods are somewhat difficult when it comes to testing. That is, while a method that conceptually has no state, at first glance, seems straightforward enough to test, the issues arise when that static method does something like hit a database or in my case, call a web service to a networked asset. There is no easy way to override such behavior (unless, of course, you pull out a hammer).

Static methods have a place. But when it comes to testing code, whether it be legacy or some 3rd party library, the static modifier requires a hammer and as I hope I’ve shown you, PowerMock is that hammer.

Reference: Sometimes TDD Requires a Hammer from our JCG partner Andrew Glover at the The Disco Blog blog.
(0 rating, 0 votes)
You need to be a registered member to rate this.
Start the discussion Views Tweet it!
Do you want to know how to develop your skillset to become a Java Rockstar?
Subscribe to our newsletter to start Rocking right now!
To get you started we give you our best selling eBooks for FREE!
1. JPA Mini Book
2. JVM Troubleshooting Guide
3. JUnit Tutorial for Unit Testing
4. Java Annotations Tutorial
5. Java Interview Questions
6. Spring Interview Questions
7. Android UI Design
and many more ....
Email address:

Leave a Reply

Be the First to Comment!

Notify of