Home » Software Development » “I don’t have to worry about Garbage collection” – Is it true?

About Ram Lakshmanan

Ram Lakshmanan
Ram Lakshmanan developed world's finest DevOps tools: GCeasy.io, fastThread.io, HeapHero.io. Every single day, millions & millions of people in North America—bank, travel, and commerce—use the applications that Ram Lakshmanan has architected. Ram is an acclaimed speaker in major conferences on scalability, availability, and performance topics. Recently, he has founded a startup, which specializes in troubleshooting performance problems.

“I don’t have to worry about Garbage collection” – Is it true?

I have heard a few of my developer friends say: “Garbage Collection is automatic. So, I do not have to worry about it.“ The first part is true, i.e., “Garbage Collection is automatic” on all modern platforms – Java, .NET, Golang, Python… But the second part i.e., “I don’t have to worry about it.” – may not be true. It is arguable, questionable. Here is my case to showcase the importance of Garbage Collection:

1. Unpleasant customer experience

When a garbage collector runs, it pauses the entire application to mark the objects that are in use and sweep away the objects that don’t have active references. During this pause period, all customer transactions which are in motion will be stalled (i.e., frozen). Depending on the type of GC algorithm and memory settings that you configure, pause times can run anywhere from a few milliseconds to a few minutes. Frequent pauses in the application can cause stuttering, juddering, or halting effects to your customers. It will leave an unpleasant experience for your customers.

2. Millions of dollars wasted

Here is a white paper we published, explaining factually how enterprises are wasting millions of dollars due to garbage collection. Basically, in a nutshell, modern applications are creating thousands/millions of objects. These objects must be continuously investigated to determine whether they have active references or are they ready for garbage collection. Once objects are garbage collected, the memory becomes fragmented. Fragmented memory must be compacted. All these activities consume *enormous compute cycles*. These compute cycles translate to millions of dollars in spending. If Garbage collection performance can be optimized, it can result in several millions of dollars in cost savings.

3. Low risk, high impact performance improvements

By virtue of optimizing Garbage collection performance, you are not only improving the Garbage collection pause time, but you are improving the overall application’s response time. We recently helped to tune the garbage collection performance of one of the world’s largest automobile companies. Just by modifying the garbage collection settings without refactoring a single line of code, we improved their overall application’s response time significantly. The below table summarizes the overall response time improvement we achieved with each Garbage Collection setting change we made: 

 Avg Response Time (secs)Transactions > 25 sec (%)
Baseline1.880.7
GC settings iteration #21.360.12
GC settings iteration #31.70.11
GC settings iteration #41.480.08
GC settings iteration #52.0450.14
GC settings iteration #61.0870.24
GC settings iteration #71.030.14
GC settings iteration #80.950.31

When we started the GC tuning exercise, this automobile application’s overall response time was 1.88 seconds. As we optimized Garbage Collection performance with different settings, on iteration #8, we were able to improve the overall response time to 0.95 seconds. i.e., 49.46% improvement in the response time.  Similarly, percentages of transactions taking more than 25 seconds dropped from 0.7% to 0.31%, i.e., 55% improvement. This is a significant improvement to achieve without modifying a single line of code. 

All other forms of response time improvement will require infrastructure change or architectural change, or code-level changes. All of them are expensive changes. Even if you embark on making those costly changes, there is no guarantee of the application’s response time improvement.

4. Predictive Monitoring

Garbage Collection logs expose vital predictive micrometrics. These metrics can be used for forecasting application’s availability and performance characteristics. One of the micrometrics exposed in Garbage Collection is ‘GC Throughput‘ (to read more about other micrometrics, refer to this article). What is GC Throughput? If your application’s GC throughput is 98%, it means your application is spending 98% of its time processing customer activity and the remaining 2% of the time in GC activity. When the application suffers from a memory problem, several minutes before GC throughput will start to degrade. Troubleshooting tools like yCrash monitors ‘GC throughput’ to predict and forecast the memory problems before they surface in the production environment.

5. Capacity Planning

When you are doing capacity planning for your application, you need to understand your application’s demand for memory, CPU, Network and storage. One of the  best ways to study the demand for memory is by analyzing garbage collection behaviour. When you analyze garbage collection behaviour, you would be able to determine average object creation rate (example: 150 MB/sec), average object reclamation rate. Using these sort of micrometrics you can do effective capacity planning for your application.

Conclusion

 Friends, in this post, I have made my best efforts to justify the importance of garbage collection analysis. I wish you and your team the best to benefit from the highly insightful garbage collection metrics.

Published on Java Code Geeks with permission by Ram Lakshmanan, partner at our JCG program. See the original article here: “I don’t have to worry about Garbage collection” – Is it true?

Opinions expressed by Java Code Geeks contributors are their own.

(0 rating, 0 votes)
You need to be a registered member to rate this.
1 Comment Views Tweet it!
Do you want to know how to develop your skillset to become a Java Rockstar?
Subscribe to our newsletter to start Rocking right now!
To get you started we give you our best selling eBooks for FREE!
1. JPA Mini Book
2. JVM Troubleshooting Guide
3. JUnit Tutorial for Unit Testing
4. Java Annotations Tutorial
5. Java Interview Questions
6. Spring Interview Questions
7. Android UI Design
and many more ....
I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

1 Comment
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Zbigniew
Zbigniew
1 month ago

Put a penny for every new operator in the app and you are done.