Home » Java » Enterprise Java » Java Thread: retained memory analysis

About Pierre Hugues Charbonneau

Pierre Hugues Charbonneau
Pierre-Hugues Charbonneau (nickname P-H) is working for CGI Inc. Canada for the last 10 years as a senior IT consultant. His primary area of expertise is Java EE, middleware & JVM technologies. He is a specialist in production system troubleshooting, root cause analysis, middleware, JVM tuning, scalability and capacity improvement; including internal processes improvement for IT support teams. P-H is the principal author at Java EE Support Patterns.

Java Thread: retained memory analysis

This article will provide you with a tutorial allowing you to determine how much and where Java heap space is retained from your active application Java threads. A true case study from an Oracle Weblogic 10.0 production environment will be presented in order for you to better understand the analysis process.

We will also attempt to demonstrate that excessive garbage collection or Java heap space memory footprint problems are often not caused by true memory leaks but instead due to thread execution patterns and high amount of short lived objects.
 
 
 

Background

As you may have seen from my past JVM overview article, Java threads are part of the JVM fundamentals. Your Java heap space memory footprint is driven not only by static and long lived objects but also by short lived objects.

OutOfMemoryError problems are often wrongly assumed to be due to memory leaks. We often overlook faulty thread execution patterns and short lived objects they “retain” on the Java heap until their executions are completed. In this problematic scenario:

  • Your “expected” application short lived / stateless objects (XML, JSON data payload etc.) become retained by the threads for too long (thread lock contention, huge data payload, slow response time from remote system etc.)
  • Eventually such short lived objects get promoted to the long lived object space e.g. OldGen/tenured space by the garbage collector
  • As a side effect, this is causing the OldGen space to fill up rapidly, increasing the Full GC (major collections) frequency
  • Depending of the severity of the situation this can lead to excessive GC garbage collection, increased JVM paused time and ultimately OutOfMemoryError: Java heap space
  • Your application is now down, you are now puzzled on what is going on
  • Finally, you are thinking to either increase the Java heap or look for memory leaks…are you really on the right track?

In the above scenario, you need to look at the thread execution patterns and determine how much memory each of them retain at a given time.

OK I get the picture but what about the thread stack size?

It is very important to avoid any confusion between thread stack size and Java memory retention. The thread stack size is a special memory space used by the JVM to store each method call. When a thread calls method A, it “pushes” the call onto the stack. If method A calls method B, it gets also pushed onto the stack. Once the method execution completes, the call is “popped” off the stack.

The Java objects created as a result of such thread method calls are allocated on the Java heap space. Increasing the thread stack size will definitely not have any effect. Tuning of the thread stack size is normally required when dealing with java.lang.stackoverflowerror or OutOfMemoryError: unable to create new native thread problems.

Case study and problem context

The following analysis is based on a true production problem we investigated recently.

  • Severe performance degradation was observed from a Weblogic 10.0 production environment following some changes to the user web interface (using Google Web Toolkit and JSON as data payload)
  • Initial analysis did reveal several occurrences of OutOfMemoryError: Java heap space errors along with excessive garbage collection. Java heap dump files were generated automatically (-XX:+HeapDumpOnOutOfMemoryError) following OOM events
  • Analysis of the verbose:gc logs did confirm full depletion of the 32-bit HotSpot JVM OldGen space (1 GB capacity)
  • Thread dump snapshots were also generated before and during the problem
  • The only problem mitigation available at that time was to restart the affected Weblogic server when problem was observed
  • A rollback of the changes was eventually performed which did resolve the situation

The team first suspected a memory leak problem from the new code introduced.

Thread dump analysis: looking for suspects…

The first analysis step we did was to perform an analysis of the generated thread dump data. Thread dump will often show you the culprit threads allocating memory on the Java heap. It will also reveal any hogging or stuck thread attempting to send and receive data payload from a remote system.

The first pattern we noticed was a good correlation between OOM events and STUCK threads observed from the Weblogic managed servers (JVM processes). Find below the primary thread pattern found:

<10-Dec-2012 1:27:59 o'clock PM EST> <Error> <BEA-000337>

<[STUCK] ExecuteThread: '22' for queue:

'weblogic.kernel.Default (self-tuning)'

has been busy for '672' seconds working on the request

which is more than the configured time of '600' seconds.

As you can see, the above thread appears to be STUCK or taking very long time to read and receive the JSON response from the remote server. Once we found that pattern, the next step was to correlate this finding with the JVM heap dump analysis and determine how much memory these stuck threads were taking from the Java heap.

Heap dump analysis: retained objects exposed!

The Java heap dump analysis was performed using MAT. We will now list the different analysis steps which did allow us to pinpoint the retained memory size and source.

1. Load the HotSpot JVM heap dump

2. Select the HISTOGRAM view and filter by “ExecuteThread”

* ExecuteThread is the Java class used by the Weblogic kernel for thread creation & execution *

As you can see, this view was quite revealing. We can see a total of 210 Weblogic threads created. The total retained memory footprint from these threads is 806 MB. This is pretty significant for a 32-bit JVM process with 1 GB OldGen space. This view alone is telling us that the core of the problem and memory retention originates from the threads themselves.

3. Deep dive into the thread memory footprint analysis

The next step was to deep dive into the thread memory retention. To do this, simply right click over the ExecuteThread class and select: List objects > with outgoing references.

As you can see, we were able to correlate STUCK threads from the thread dump analysis with high memory retention from the heap dump analysis. The finding was quite surprising.

4. Thread Java Local variables identification

The final analysis step did require us to expand a few thread samples and understand the primary source of memory retention.

As you can see, this last analysis step did reveal huge JSON response data payload at the root cause. That pattern was also exposed earlier via the thread dump analysis where we found a few threads taking very long time to read & receive the JSON response; a clear symptom of huge data payload footprint.

It is crucial to note that short lived objects created via local method variables will show up in the heap dump analysis. However, some of those will only be visible from their parent threads since they are not referenced by other objects, like in this case. You will also need to analyze the thread stack trace in order to identify the true caller, followed by a code review to confirm the root cause.

Following this finding, our delivery team was able to determine that the recent JSON faulty code changes were generating, under some scenarios, huge JSON data payload up to 45 MB+. Given the fact that this environment is using a 32-bit JVM with only 1 GB of OldGen space, you can understand that only a few threads were enough to trigger severe performance degradation.

This case study is clearly showing the importance of proper capacity planning and Java heap analysis, including the memory retained from your active application & Java EE container threads.

Learning is experience. Everything else is just information

I hope this article has helped you understand how you can pinpoint the Java heap memory footprint retained by your active threads by combining thread dump and heap dump analysis. Now, this article will remain just words if you don’t experiment so I highly recommend that you take some time to learn this analysis process yourself for your application(s).
 

Reference: Java Thread: retained memory analysis from our JCG partner Pierre-Hugues Charbonneau at the Java EE Support Patterns & Java Tutorial blog.

Do you want to know how to develop your skillset to become a Java Rockstar?
Subscribe to our newsletter to start Rocking right now!
To get you started we give you our best selling eBooks for FREE!
1. JPA Mini Book
2. JVM Troubleshooting Guide
3. JUnit Tutorial for Unit Testing
4. Java Annotations Tutorial
5. Java Interview Questions
6. Spring Interview Questions
7. Android UI Design
and many more ....
Email address:

Leave a Reply

1 Comment on "Java Thread: retained memory analysis"

avatar
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Harsh Gupta
Guest

Really an informative article. This article did remind me of one of the problems that i encountered while working in one of the fortune 100 MNC company where huge xml data was pushed by client machines to server and server used to choke. Although i was not able to spend too much of time figuring the cause but some of the basic analysis that was done, was not useful in finding the exact cause. Eventually i left the company and not sure what happened after that.

Want to take your Java skills to the next level?
Grab our programming books for FREE!
Here are some of the eBooks you will get:
  • Spring Interview QnA
  • Multithreading & Concurrency QnA
  • JPA Minibook
  • JVM Troubleshooting Guide
  • Advanced Java
  • Java Interview QnA
  • Java Design Patterns
The Spring Framework Cookbook
  • Learn the best practices of the Spring Framework
  • Build simple, portable, fast and flexible JVM-based systems and applications
  • Explore specific projects like Boot and Batch
The Spring Data Programming Cookbook
  • Learn how to use data access technologies and cloud-based data services
  • Set up the environment and create a basic project
  • Learn how to handle the various modules (e.g. JPA, MongoDB, Redis etc.)
The Selenium Programming Cookbook
  • Kick-start your own projects using this testing framework for web applications
  • Learn JUnit integration and Standalone Server functionality
  • Find out the most popular Interview Questions about the Selenium Framework
The Mockito Programming Cookbook
  • Kick-start your own web projects using this open source testing framework
  • Write simple test cases using the Mockito Framework
  • Learn how to integrate with JUnit, Maven and other frameworks
The JUnit Programming Cookbook
  • Learn basic usage and configuration of JUnit
  • Create multithreaded tests
  • Learn how to integrate with other testing frameworks
The JSF 2.0 Programming Cookbook
  • Build component-based user interfaces for web applications
  • Set up the environment and create a basic project
  • Learn Internationalization and Facelets Templates
The Amazon S3 Tutorial
  • Develop your own Amazon S3 based applications
  • Learn API usage and pricing
  • Get your own projects up and running in minimum time
Java Design Patterns
  • Learn how Design Patterns are implemented and utilized in Java
  • Understand the reasons why patterns are so important
  • Learn when and how to apply each one of them
Java Concurrency Essentials
  • Dive into the magic of concurrency
  • Learn about concepts like atomicity, synchronization and thread safety
  • Learn about testing concurrent applications
The IntelliJ IDEA Handbook
  • Kick-start your own programming projects using IntelliJ IDEA
  • Learn how to setup and install plugins
  • Create UIs with this Java integrated development environment
The Git Tutorial
  • Learn why Git differs from other version control systems
  • Explore Git's usage and best practises
  • Learn branching strategies
The Eclipse IDE Handbook
  • Explore the most widely used Java IDE
  • Learn how to setup and install plugins
  • Built your own projects up and running in minimum time
The Docker Containerization Cookbook
  • Explore the world’s leading software containerization platform
  • Learn how to wrap a piece of software in a complete filesystem
  • Learn how to use DNS and various commands
Developing Modern Applications With Scala
  • Develop modern Scala applications
  • Build SBT and reactive applications
  • Learn about testing and database access
The Apache Tomcat Cookbook
  • Explore Apache Tomcat open-source web server
  • Learn about installation, configuration, logging and clustering
  • Kick-start your own web projects using Apache Tomcat
The Apache Maven Cookbook
  • Explore the Apache Maven build automation tool
  • Learn about Maven's project structure and configuration
  • Learn about Maven's dependency management and plug-ins
The Apache Hadoop Cookbook
  • Explore the Apache Hadoop open-source software framework
  • Learn distributed caching and streaming
  • Kick-start your own web projects using Apache Hadoop
The Android Programming Cookbook
  • Explore the Android mobile operating system
  • Learn about services and page views
  • Learn about Google Maps and Bluetooth functionality
The Elasticsearch Tutorial
  • Explore the Elasticsearch search engine
  • Develop your own Elasticsearch based applications
  • Learn operations, Java API Integration and reporting
Amazon DynamoDB Tutorial
  • Develop your own Amazon DynamoDB based applications
  • Learn DynamoDB Concepts and Best Practices
  • Get your own projects up and running in minimum time
Java NIO Programming Cookbook
  • Learn features for intensive I/O operations
  • Follow a series of tutorials on Java NIO examples
  • Get knowledge on Java Nio Socket and Asynchronous Channels
JBoss Drools Cookbook
  • Explore Drools business rule management system
  • Follow a series of tutorials on Drools examples
  • Get knowledge on business rules for a shopping domain model
Vaadin Programming Cookbook
  • Explore Vaadin web framework for rich Internet applications
  • Learn the Architecture and Best Practices
  • Get knowledge on Data Binding and Custom Components
Groovy Programming Cookbook
  • Explore Apache Groovy object-oriented programming language
  • Create sample applications and explore interview questions
  • Get knowledge on Callback functionality and various widgets
GWT Programming Cookbook
  • Explore the open source Google Web Toolkit
  • Create sample applications and explore interview questions
  • Create and maintain complex JavaScript front-end applications in Java
Do you want to know how to develop your skillset to become a Java Rockstar?
Subscribe to our newsletter to start Rocking right now!
To get you started we give you our best selling eBooks for FREE!
1. JPA Mini Book
2. JVM Troubleshooting Guide
3. JUnit Tutorial for Unit Testing
4. Java Annotations Tutorial
5. Java Interview Questions
and many more ....
Email address:
Do you want to know how to develop your skillset to become a Java Rockstar?
Subscribe to our newsletter to start Rocking right now!
To get you started we give you our best selling eBooks for FREE!
1. JPA Mini Book
2. JVM Troubleshooting Guide
3. JUnit Tutorial for Unit Testing
4. Java Annotations Tutorial
5. Java Interview Questions
and many more ....
Email address:
Do you want to know how to develop your skillset to become a Java Rockstar?
Subscribe to our newsletter to start Rocking right now!
To get you started we give you our best selling eBooks for FREE!
1. JPA Mini Book
2. JVM Troubleshooting Guide
3. JUnit Tutorial for Unit Testing
4. Java Annotations Tutorial
5. Java Interview Questions
6. Spring Interview Questions
7. Android UI Design
and many more ....
Email address:
Want to be a DynamoDB Master ?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the Amazon DynamoDB Tutorial right now!
In order to help you master this Amazon NoSQL database service, we have compiled a kick-ass guide with all the major DynamoDB features and use cases! Besides studying them online you may download the eBook in PDF format!
Email address:
Programming Interview Coming Up?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the Ultimate Multithreading and Concurrency interview questions and answers collection right now!
In order to get you prepared for your next Programming Interview, we have compiled a huge list of relevant Questions and their respective Answers. Besides studying them online you may download the eBook in PDF format!
Email address:
Java Interview Coming Up?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the Ultimate Spring interview questions and answers collection right now!
In order to get you prepared for your next Java Interview, we have compiled a huge list of relevant Questions and their respective Answers. Besides studying them online you may download the eBook in PDF format!
Email address:
Java Interview Coming Up?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the Ultimate Java interview questions and answers collection right now!
In order to get you prepared for your next Java Interview, we have compiled a huge list of relevant Questions and their respective Answers. Besides studying them online you may download the eBook in PDF format!
Email address:
Want to be a Java NIO Master ?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the Java NIO Programming Cookbook right now!
In order to help you master Java NIO Library, we have compiled a kick-ass guide with all the major Java NIO features and use cases! Besides studying them online you may download the eBook in PDF format!
Email address:
Want to be a Drools Master ?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the JBoss Drools Cookbook right now!
In order to help you master Drools Business Rule Management System, we have compiled a kick-ass guide with all the major Drools features and use cases! Besides studying them online you may download the eBook in PDF format!
Email address:
Want to be an iText Master ?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the iText Tutorial right now!
In order to help you master iText Library, we have compiled a kick-ass guide with all the major iText features and use cases! Besides studying them online you may download the eBook in PDF format!
Email address:
Want to be an Elasticsearch Master ?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the Elasticsearch Tutorial right now!
In order to help you master Elasticsearch search engine, we have compiled a kick-ass guide with all the major Elasticsearch features and use cases! Besides studying them online you may download the eBook in PDF format!
Email address:
Want to be a Scala Master ?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the Scala Cookbook right now!
In order to help you master Scala, we have compiled a kick-ass guide with all the basic concepts! Besides studying them online you may download the eBook in PDF format!
Email address:
Want to be a JUnit Master ?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the JUnit Programming Cookbook right now!
In order to help you master unit testing with JUnit, we have compiled a kick-ass guide with all the major JUnit features and use cases! Besides studying them online you may download the eBook in PDF format!
Email address:
Want to master Amazon Web Services ?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the Amazon S3 Tutorial right now!
In order to help you master the leading Web Services platform, we have compiled a kick-ass guide with all its major features and use cases! Besides studying them online you may download the eBook in PDF format!
Email address:
Want to master Spring Framework ?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the Spring Framework Cookbook right now!
In order to help you master the leading and innovative Java framework, we have compiled a kick-ass guide with all its major features and use cases! Besides studying them online you may download the eBook in PDF format!
Email address:
Want to master Eclipse IDE ?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the Eclipse IDE Handbook right now!
In order to help you master Eclipse, we have compiled a kick-ass guide with all the basic features of the popular IDE! Besides studying them online you may download the eBook in PDF format!
Email address:
Want to master IntelliJ IDEA ?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the IntelliJ IDEA Handbook right now!
In order to help you master IntelliJ IDEA, we have compiled a kick-ass guide with all the basic features of the popular IDE! Besides studying them online you may download the eBook in PDF format!
Email address:
Want to master Docker ?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the Docker Containerization Cookbook right now!
In order to help you master Docker, we have compiled a kick-ass guide with all the basic concepts of the Docker container system! Besides studying them online you may download the eBook in PDF format!
Email address:
Want to create a kick-ass Android App ?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the Android Programming Cookbook right now!
With this book, you will delve into the fundamentals of Android programming. You will understand user input, views and layouts. Furthermore, you will learn how to communicate over Bluetooth and also leverage Google Maps into your application!
Email address:
Want to be a GIT Master ?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the GIT Tutorial eBook right now!
In order to help you master GIT, we have compiled a kick-ass guide with all the basic concepts of the GIT version control system! Besides studying them online you may download the eBook in PDF format!
Email address:
Want to be a Hadoop Master ?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the Apache Hadoop Cookbook right now!
In order to help you master Apache Hadoop, we have compiled a kick-ass guide with all the basic concepts of a Hadoop cluster! Besides studying them online you may download the eBook in PDF format!
Email address:
Want to master Spring Data ?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the Spring Data Ultimate Guide right now!
In order to help you master Spring Data, we have compiled a kick-ass guide with all the major features and use cases! Besides studying them online you may download the eBook in PDF format!
Email address:
Want to create a kick-ass Android App ?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the Android UI Design mini-book right now!
With this book, you will delve into the fundamentals of Android UI design. You will understand user input, views and layouts, as well as adapters and fragments. Furthermore, you will learn how to add multimedia to an app and also leverage themes and styles!
Email address:
Want to be a Java 8 Ninja ?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the Java 8 Features Ultimate Guide right now!
In order to get you up to speed with the major Java 8 release, we have compiled a kick-ass guide with all the new features and goodies! Besides studying them online you may download the eBook in PDF format!
Email address:
Want to master Java Annotations ?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the Java Annotations Ultimate Guide right now!
In order to help you master the topic of Annotations, we have compiled a kick-ass guide with all the major features and use cases! Besides studying them online you may download the eBook in PDF format!
Email address:
Want to be a JUnit Master ?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the JUnit Ultimate Guide right now!
In order to help you master unit testing with JUnit, we have compiled a kick-ass guide with all the major JUnit features and use cases! Besides studying them online you may download the eBook in PDF format!
Email address:
Want to master Java Abstraction ?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the Abstraction in Java Ultimate Guide right now!
In order to help you master the topic of Abstraction, we have compiled a kick-ass guide with all the major features and use cases! Besides studying them online you may download the eBook in PDF format!
Email address:
Want to master Java Reflection ?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the Java Reflection Ultimate Guide right now!
In order to help you master the topic of Reflection, we have compiled a kick-ass guide with all the major features and use cases! Besides studying them online you may download the eBook in PDF format!
Email address:
Want to be a JMeter Master ?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the JMeter Ultimate Guide right now!
In order to help you master load testing with JMeter, we have compiled a kick-ass guide with all the major JMeter features and use cases! Besides studying them online you may download the eBook in PDF format!
Email address:
Want to be a Servlets Master ?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the Java Servlet Ultimate Guide right now!
In order to help you master programming with Java Servlets, we have compiled a kick-ass guide with all the major servlet API uses and showcases! Besides studying them online you may download the eBook in PDF format!
Email address:
Want to be a JAXB Master ?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the JAXB Ultimate Guide right now!
In order to help you master XML Binding with JAXB, we have compiled a kick-ass guide with all the major JAXB features and use cases! Besides studying them online you may download the eBook in PDF format!
Email address:
Want to be a JDBC Master ?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the JDBC Ultimate Guide right now!
In order to help you master database programming with JDBC, we have compiled a kick-ass guide with all the major JDBC features and use cases! Besides studying them online you may download the eBook in PDF format!
Email address:
Want to be a JPA Master ?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the JPA Ultimate Guide right now!
In order to help you master programming with JPA, we have compiled a kick-ass guide with all the major JPA features and use cases! Besides studying them online you may download the eBook in PDF format!
Email address:
Want to be a Hibernate Master ?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the Hibernate Ultimate Guide right now!
In order to help you master JPA and database programming with Hibernate, we have compiled a kick-ass guide with all the major Hibernate features and use cases! Besides studying them online you may download the eBook in PDF format!
Email address:
Want to be a JSF Master ?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the JSF 2.0 Programming Cookbook right now!
In order to get you prepared for your JSF development needs, we have compiled numerous recipes to help you kick-start your projects. Besides reading them online you may download the eBook in PDF format!
Email address:
Want to be a Java Master ?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the Advanced Java Guide right now!
In order to help you master the Java programming language, we have compiled a kick-ass guide with all the must-know advanced Java features! Besides studying them online you may download the eBook in PDF format!
Email address:
Want to be a Java Master ?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the Java Design Patterns right now!
In order to help you master the Java programming language, we have compiled a kick-ass guide with all the must-know Design Patterns for Java! Besides studying them online you may download the eBook in PDF format!
Email address:
Want to be a Hadoop Master ?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the Hadoop Tutorial right now!
In order to help you master Apache Hadoop, we have compiled a kick-ass guide with all the basic concepts of a Hadoop cluster! Besides studying them online you may download the eBook in PDF format!
Email address:
Want to be an Elastic Beanstalk Master ?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the Amazon Elastic Beanstalk Tutorial right now!
In order to help you master AWS Elastic Beanstalk, we have compiled a kick-ass guide with all the major Elastic Beanstalk features and use cases! Besides studying them online you may download the eBook in PDF format!
Email address:
Amazon Elastic Beanstalk Tutorial
  • Develop your own Amazon Elastic Beanstalk based applications
  • Learn Java Integration and Command Line Interfacing
  • Get your own projects up and running in minimum time
Want to take your Java skills to the next level?
Grab our programming books for FREE!
Here are some of the eBooks you will get:
  • Spring Interview QnA
  • Multithreading & Concurrency QnA
  • JPA Minibook
  • JVM Troubleshooting Guide
  • Advanced Java
  • Java Interview QnA
  • Java Design Patterns
Insiders are already enjoying weekly updates and complimentary whitepapers!
Join them now to gain exclusive access to the latest news in the Java world, as well as insights about Android, Scala, Groovy and other related technologies.
Email address:
Want to be an ActiveMQ Master ?
Subscribe to our newsletter and download the Apache ActiveMQ Cookbook right now!
In order to help you master Apache ActiveMQ JMS, we have compiled a kick-ass guide with all the major ActiveMQ features and use cases! Besides studying them online you may download the eBook in PDF format!
Email address:
Apache ActiveMQ Cookbook
  • Explore Apache ActiveMQ Best Practices
  • Learn ActiveMQ Load Balancing and File Transfer
  • Develop your own Apache ActiveMQ projects