In this post, we’ll look at how the big BDD and the smaller TDD feedback loops eliminate waste and how you can visualize that waste using code coverage tools like EclEmma to see whether you execute your process well.
The Relation Between BDD and TDD
Depending on your situation, running BDD scenarios may take a lot of time. For instance, you may need to first create a Web Application Archive (WAR), then start a web server, deploy your WAR, and finally run your automated acceptance tests using Selenium.
This is not a convenient feedback cycle to run for every single line of code you write.
So chances are that you’ll write bigger chunks of code. That increases the risk of introducing mistakes, however. Baby steps can mitigate that risk. In this case, that means moving to Test-First programming, preferably Test-Driven Development (TDD).
The link between a BDD scenario and a bunch of unit tests is the top-down test. The top-down test is a translation of the BDD scenario into test code. From there, you descend further down into unit tests using regular TDD.
This translation of BDD scenarios into top-down tests may seem wasteful, but it’s not.
Top-down tests only serve to give the developer a shorter feedback cycle. You should never have to leave your IDE to determine whether you’re done. The waste of the translation is more than made up for by the gains of not having to constantly switch to the larger BDD feedback cycle. By doing a little bit more work, you end up going faster!
If you’re worried about your build time increasing because of these top-down tests, you may even consider removing them after you’ve made them pass, since their risk-reducing job is then done.
Both BDD and TDD Eliminate Waste Using JIT Programming
There are many reasons why you’d want to eliminate unnecessary code:
- Since it takes time to write code, writing less code means you’ll be more productive (finish more stories per iteration)
- More code means more bugs
- In particular, more code means more opportunities for security vulnerabilities
- More code means more things a future maintainer must understand, and thus a higher risk of bugs introduced during maintenance due to misunderstandings
Code Coverage Can Visualize Waste
With BDD and TDD in your software development process, you expect less waste. That’s the theory, at least. How do we prove this in practice?
Well, let’s look at the process:
- BDD scenarios define the acceptance criteria for the user stories
- Those BDD scenarios are translated into top-down tests
- Those top-down tests lead to unit tests
- Finally, those unit tests lead to production code
The last step is easiest to verify: no code should have been written that wasn’t necessary for making some unit test pass. We can prove that by measuring code coverage while we execute the unit tests. Any code that is not covered is by definition waste.
EclEmma Shows Code Coverage in Eclipse
EclEmma turns covered lines green, uncovered lines red, and partially covered lines yellow.
You can change these colors using
Window|Preferences|Java|Code coverage. For instance, you could change
Full Coverage to white, so that the normal case doesn’t introduce visual clutter and only the exceptions stand out.
The great thing about EclEmma is that it let’s you measure code coverage without making you change the way you work.
The only difference is that instead of choosing
Run As|JUnit Test (or
Alt+Shift+X, T), you now choose
Coverage As|JUnit test (or
Alt+Shift+E, T). To re-run the last coverage, use
Ctrl+Shift+F11 (instead of
Ctrl+F11 to re-run the last launch).
If your fingers are conditioned to use
Alt+Shift+X, T and/or
Ctrl+F11, you can always change the key bindings using
In my experience, the performance overhead of EclEmma is low enough that you can use it all the time.
EclEmma Helps You Monitor Your Agile Process
The feedback from EclEmma allows you to immediately see any waste in the form of unnecessary code. Since there shouldn’t be any such waste if you do BDD and TDD well, the feedback from EclEmma is really feedback on how well you execute your BDD/TDD process. You can use this feedback to hone your skills and become the best developer you can be.